Is Buying an Elliptical Worth it, or Should I Get a Gym Membership?

Are you having difficulty deciding between getting a treadmill for your home or signing up for a gym membership? It’s a common struggle, especially if you love running and have specific fitness goals!

While a treadmill might seem like a convenient option, there are a few things to think about. Additionally, having a treadmill at home means working out whenever you want without traveling to a gym.

However, treadmills can be pricey, take up valuable space, and break down over time, leading to potential repair costs. Plus, they may not provide the versatility you need for a balanced workout routine.

In contrast, signing up for a gym membership gives you access to various fitness equipment, including treadmills, stair climbers, rowing machines, and free weights, all under one roof. At Crunch, for example, you can use treadmills and have access to classes, trainers, and HIIT training, which can help you more effectively reach your fitness goals.

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each option and help you decide which is the better fit for your fitness journey. Keep reading to discover how a gym membership might offer more variety, flexibility, and value than a costly treadmill purchase!

Elliptical Machine VS. Gym Membership: Comparison

Cost

Elliptical Machine

Buying an elliptical can be a significant upfront investment. A standard elliptical typically costs between $1,000 and $3,000, depending on the brand and features. High-end models with advanced settings and smooth resistance systems can exceed $7,000. While this is a one-time purchase, you’ll also need to factor in additional maintenance, repairs, or upgrade costs. If you’re looking for an elliptical comparable to those at a gym, you’ll likely need to invest in a pricier model to get the same quality and durability.

Gym Memberships

Gym memberships generally cost between $10 and $50 per month, depending on the location and amenities. While the cost may seem recurring, it grants access to a range of fitness equipment—not just ellipticals but also treadmills, stair climbers, rowing machines, free weights, and more. You’ll also be able to take advantage of fitness classes, trainers, and group workouts. Over time, the type of equipment and resources available at the gym provides a better cost-to-value ratio than buying one single machine for home use.

Crunch gym memberships are affordable and easy to sign up for, offering far more than what you’d get with home equipment. For just as little as $9.99 per month, you can access a full range of high-quality machines, group fitness classes like yoga and cycling, and amenities like saunas and personal training.

Maintenance

Elliptical Machine

Ellipticals require regular maintenance to keep them running smoothly. Over time, belts, pedals, and resistance systems can wear down, leading to costly repairs. Even if you’re handy, routine maintenance—like cleaning, lubricating moving parts, or tightening screws—takes time. And if something goes wrong, professional repair services can be expensive, especially for high-end models.

Gym Memberships

Maintenance is never a concern with a gym membership. The gym staff ensures that all machines are functioning properly and regularly serviced. If a machine breaks, they must fix or replace it. You can use the equipment without the hassle or expense of maintaining it, making your fitness experience much more convenient.

Convenience

Elliptical Machine

The biggest advantage of owning an elliptical at home is convenience. You can work out anytime, day or night, without worrying about gym hours or commuting. This option makes it easier to squeeze in short workouts throughout the day. However, the flip side is that you’re limited to just one machine and need the self-discipline to use it consistently.

Gym Memberships

While going to the gym requires some extra time, the range of equipment and classes available makes the trip worth it. You are also motivated to be in a dedicated fitness space, which can help you stay on track with your workouts. And the best part? Many gyms have flexible hours or 24/7 access, offering plenty of convenience to fit around your schedule.

Space Requirements

Elliptical Machine

Elliptical machines are big and can take up a lot of space. Finding room for one may be challenging if you live in a small apartment or have limited space. Additionally, you’ll need extra room around the machine for safe use. The space it occupies is something to think about before making a purchase.

Gym Memberships

With a gym membership, space is not an issue. You don’t have to dedicate any room at home to fitness equipment because everything you need is available at the gym. Whether you want to use an elliptical, treadmill, or free weights, the gym provides all the space you need without cluttering your home.

Cardio

Elliptical Machine

Ellipticals are excellent for low-impact cardio workouts. They allow you to elevate your heart rate and burn calories without putting too much strain on your joints, making them ideal for people with knee or hip issues. However, the cardio options are limited to what the elliptical can provide, which may become repetitive over time.

Gym Memberships

At the gyms, you can access many cardio equipment, from ellipticals to treadmills, stationary bikes, rowing machines, and stair climbers. This variety ensures you can switch up your routine to keep things fresh and challenge different muscle groups. Having multiple cardio options at your fingertips makes it easier to stay engaged and motivated.

Strength Training

Elliptical Machine

Using Ellipticals can improve your cardio. While they engage your lower body and core muscles, they don’t provide the same strength training as free weights or resistance machines. Some ellipticals have moving handles to engage your upper body but offer a different intensity than dedicated strength workouts.

Gym Memberships

Gym memberships open up a world of strength training possibilities. In addition to cardio machines, you’ll have access to free weights, resistance machines, and equipment like kettlebells and medicine balls. This diversity enables you to work on different muscle groups and build strength more effectively than just an elliptical.

Weight Loss

Elliptical Machine

Ellipticals can support weight loss by providing consistent cardio workouts that help burn calories. If used regularly, they can certainly contribute to shedding pounds. However, incorporating strength training and diversity in your cardio routine is essential for optimal weight loss—something an elliptical alone can’t provide.

Gym Memberships

Gyms offer a more comprehensive approach to weight loss. You can combine cardio sessions with strength training, which is key to boosting your metabolism and burning more calories overall. Plus, with access to fitness classes like HIIT (High-Intensity Interval Training) and support from trainers, you can tailor your workouts specifically to your weight loss goals.

Enjoyment

Elliptical Machine

Ellipticals can be enjoyable for people who prefer low-impact, repetitive motion workouts. However, after a while, working out on the same machine can become monotonous, which may lead to a lack of motivation or boredom. You’ll need to be someone who enjoys using an elliptical to make it a sustainable part of your routine.

Gym Memberships

The gym provides a dynamic environment that can keep you engaged and excited about working out. With different machines, fitness classes, and equipment, you can constantly change your routine to keep things interesting. Meeting or working out with other gym-goers can also add motivation and enjoyment to your fitness journey.

Is an Elliptical Machine the Right Fitness Equipment for Your Own Home Gym?

Elliptical machines are fantastic exercise equipment, especially if you’re looking for a low-impact workout that’s easy on your joints. An elliptical could be a valuable investment for those with specific fitness goals—such as improving cardiovascular health or easing into exercise after an injury.

They provide a consistent cardio routine that can be done in the comfort of your own home. However, there are better routes than this for most people, especially when considering the cost, maintenance, and long-term value.

Ellipticals are expensive, often ranging from $1,000 to several thousand dollars, and they take up a significant amount of space in your home. Over time, they can break down, leading to additional repair costs. Plus, working out on the same machine day after day can quickly become monotonous, potentially dampening your motivation.

By contrast, a gym membership offers a wide variety of equipment—ellipticals, treadmills, strength machines, free weights, and more—for a fraction of the price.

Should you Buy an Elliptical or Get a Gym Membership?

If you want a complete fitness experience, getting a gym membership is often better than investing in just one piece of equipment, like an elliptical. A gym offers so much more than a single machine—you get access to a wide variety of equipment, expert help from trainers, and the chance to join a community of people who share similar goals.

This diversity keeps your workouts fresh and helps you stay motivated and on track toward achieving your fitness objectives. Gyms also have extra perks, such as online workout programs and lower injury risk from properly maintained equipment.

Equipment Variety

When you join a gym, you can use the same machine daily as you would with an elliptical. You can switch things up with treadmills, rowing machines, stair climbers, and free weights, allowing you to target different muscle groups and avoid getting bored. This variety lets you customize your workouts based on your fitness goals, whether building muscle, improving endurance, or losing weight.

Group Classes

One of the best parts of having a gym membership is the range of group fitness classes available. Whether you’re into high-intensity cycling, dance, or calming yoga, gyms offer something for everyone. These classes provide an energetic, fun environment where you can learn new exercises, challenge yourself, and stay committed to your fitness routine. Plus, having an instructor there gives you the guidance to maximize each workout.

New Friendships

Gyms are more than just places to work out; they’re communities where you can meet people with similar fitness goals. Whether it’s a casual conversation after a class or finding a workout buddy, the social aspect of gyms helps keep you motivated and makes working out more enjoyable. These connections can increase accountability, making it easier to stick to your routine and push yourself.

Personal Training

Many gyms offer personal training services, which can greatly benefit you if you’re serious about reaching your goals. Personal trainers help design a workout plan tailored to your needs and ensure you use the proper form to avoid injury. They encourage and track your progress, which can be incredibly motivating. Whether you’re just starting or experienced, a trainer can help you get better results in less time.

Access to Online Workouts & Other Perks

Most gyms today offer more than just in-person workouts—they provide access to online classes and apps, making it easy to stay active no matter where you are. This flexibility is great if you travel often or prefer to work out at home occasionally. Additionally, many gyms have extra perks like saunas, pools, and recovery areas, which can enhance your experience and aid in relaxation after a hard workout.

Less Chance of Injury

Gym equipment can help reduce the risk of injury because everything is professionally maintained and regularly inspected. Plus, with trainers and instructors, you’ll get guidance on how to use machines correctly and safely. This is especially important for beginners, as learning the right techniques from the start can prevent long-term injuries.

Accountability & Motivation

One key advantage of a gym membership is the built-in motivation. Whether it’s the energy of a busy gym, a class instructor’s encouragement, or a workout buddy’s accountability, the gym environment naturally keeps you on track. Many gyms also offer challenges or track your progress, which can be a fun way to stay motivated as you reach your fitness goals.

Faster Results

With all the tools, resources, and support a gym offers you’re more likely to see results faster than working out at home. Having everything you need for strength and cardio training allows you to follow a balanced plan that addresses all fitness areas. Combining equipment, classes, personal training, and a motivating atmosphere helps you stay consistent and progress efficiently.

Reach Your Fitness Goals With Crunch

Crunch promotes a culture of positivity, inclusivity, and fun with no judgments by providing an environment for all individuals regardless of their health and fitness goals. Find a Crunch gym near you to try our free trial membership, or join Crunch now. We’re here for you – at the gym or at home. Access the best live & on-demand workouts anytime, anywhere with Crunch+. Ready to get sweaty? Try hundreds of workouts for free! Start your free trial now!